This Side of the Law

/ Colin McGuigan

Years ago, when I took my first tentative steps into the world of blogging, I wanted to find some means of talking about the movies which I found interesting. The thing was those films all too often were of a kind that had, let’s say, a somewhat limited following, material that might be obscure but didn’t have the benefit of carrying the cult label. Ever since, I’ve branched out a bit and I like to mix it up, featuring the better known and more critically celebrated alongside the forgotten and the neglected. Still, I want to return on a fairly regular basis to those movies in the latter category, to focus a light on the overlooked corners of cinema’s past and either remind people of something they once saw or, where possible, introduce it to a potentially new audience. With that in mind, let’s pay a visit to This Side of the Law (1950), a small scale and unheralded piece of mystery/noir.

The flashback is a wonderful noir device, offering up someone in a sticky situation and then inviting the audience to step back into the past to see if we can understand exactly how they wound up in trouble. That’s how This Side of the Law opens, with a man quite literally in a hole. David Cummins (Kent Smith) is trapped, bruised and despairing, lying sprawled in the depths of a slimy underground cistern, shut off from the world above and waiting to die. How did he get here? Well, Cummins is a bum, a man who has been picked up and run in on a vagrancy charge. However, instead of doing his time quietly and anonymously, he is spotted by sharp lawyer Philip Cagle (Robert Douglas) who is stunned by Cummins’ resemblance to a former client. And so Cummins sees his life transformed; persuaded by Cagle to take on the identity of a missing millionaire for a brief time, he genuinely goes from rags to riches. The problem is his relatives are less than pleased to see the wanderer return – his weak-willed brother (John Alvin) and adulterous sister-in-law (Janis Paige) are respectively outraged and bemused. And then there is the wife (Viveca Lindfors), unsure of how she feels about the reappearance of a man for whom she held mixed feelings. Of course when a man is as unwelcome as this guy, you have to wonder how long he’ll be allowed to stick around…

Director Richard L Bare spent the majority of his career making Joe McDoakes shorts and then moved on to plenty of television work. His features are few in number but his budget-conscious background seems to have taught him how to get the best out of limited resources. This Side of the Law has a standard plot, one that isn’t going to surprise too many viewers but it’s pretty enjoyable in spite of that. Sure it’s a hoary old yarn and the twists are easy enough to spot in advance. But it looks splendid, one of those productions where the studio sets are a genuine asset. In fairness, much of this is down to the expert cinematography of Carl Guthrie, a man who was something of a genius behind the camera and who created magical and beautifully lit images in countless set-bound films.

Kent Smith never quite made it as a leading man, although he had a long career and was involved in some memorable films along the way. This Side of the Law was a B movie but he did good work in a number of low budget efforts such as this. Tightly made productions don’t give many opportunities for nuance or subtlety but I think Smith managed to convey some in his performance, never overplaying and tapping into the uncertainty and trepidation of his character very credibly. Swedish actress Lindfors is fine as the puzzled wife and also underplays skillfully. On the other hand, Janis Paige vamps successfully and uses her insolent sexuality effectively. I feel John Alvin could have been a bit more restrained as the cuckolded younger brother and would have preferred it if he had reined it in a little. And Robert Douglas, well he was an old pro and very smooth.

This Side of the Law was a Warner Brothers production and has been released on DVD as part of the MOD Archive range in the US and there is also a low-cost DVD available from Italy. The film appears to be in good condition and shows off Guthrie’s photography nicely. Frankly, I like this kind of modest fare, and the moodily expressive cinematography is a big bonus. The film is no world-beater and I have no intention of trying to sell it as such. However, it is enjoyable, good-looking and features a handful of solid performances. If you have the opportunity, give it a try as there are far worse ways of passing an hour and a quarter.

25 thoughts on “This Side of the Law”

  1. Really glad to see you drawing attention to works like this. I could watch atmospheric, small-scale movies like this all day – or at least throughout an extended rainy afternoon! Well, you probably know what I’m going to say here as I’ll be off to the get the Italian edition shortly 🙂

    Like

    Reply

  2. Colin, a good write-up of what I think blogs are made for. You said it best and it is worth repeating here, ” featuring the better known and more critically celebrated alongside the forgotten and the neglected.” I think that just because a movie is forgotten and neglected, doesn’t mean it isn’t worth watching. Fact is, far from it. An individual might actually like this new movie and as we well know, It is a new movie if you’ve never viewed it, whether it be from 1950, or 2019.

    THIS SIDE OF THE LAW, doesn’t trigger my memory and I have seen a lot of Warner Bros. movies. So, thank you for placing this little engine that could in my view mirror.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  6. There are many of us who love to dwell in the world of creativity vs budget. It’s a treasure hunt, and perhaps our treasure is another person’s trash, but that’s their loss. This is a new title to me and I am grateful to add it to the list of “Ooh, I want to see that.”

    – Caftan Woman

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    • Yes, another nice turn of phrase as there are indeed loads of hidden treasures out there. Sure everyone won’t react the same way to all of them, but seeking them out in the first place is half the fun for me anyway.

      Like

      Reply

  7. Well done, Colin! I love having little rarities like this brought to my attention. No world-beater perhaps but very much the kind of film I enjoy. I was unaware of “THIS SIDE OF THE LAW” but not for much longer as I too have ordered it for £6.
    I like Kent Smith in some ways for his very ‘ordinaryness’. Thought he was good in “CAT PEOPLE”.

    Like

    Reply

    • Again, I do hope the film proves satisfying, Jerry. I like Kent Smith too and I think movies need those everyman types as much as the more idiosyncratic individuals. Cat People is arguably his best known part, for good reason, but I feel he was good in Party Girl and The Badlanders too.

      Like

      Reply

  8. I just saw this one and thought it was very good. It was the first time though that I didn’t find Kent Smith completely dull, as in Cat People and Nora Prentiss. His problem wasn’t a lack of acting talent but a lack of screen presence. But he fared quite well here though Janis Paige steals the show.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    • Now that you remind me, I still haven’t seen Nora Prentiss – something else to keep in mind.

      Yes, Janis Paige gets the showy part and really runs with it. Glad you liked the film, and thanks for taking the time to come back and share your thoughts.

      Like

      Reply

      • I saw Nora Prentiss years ago and liked it a great deal. I recall describing it as a noirish melodrama rather than a film noir, and that ticks two of my boxes straight away. I also recall thinking it was quirky, which ticks another of my boxes.

        It’s the sort of movie that at the time would have been regarded as a “women’s picture” – another term that like melodrama used to get used a lot in a pejorative manner.

        I’d recommend it highly.

        This Side of the Law is a fine little movie. There’s nothing more pleasing than coming across a totally neglected B-movie and discovering that it’s a really really good movie.

        Liked by 1 person

        Reply

  9. Colin
    I always love it when others see in a film what had grabbed me as well. This one fires on all cylinders if you ask me. I also did this one as a Noir of the Week.. The bit where he is at the bottom of the old well and realizes he has been played for a world class chump is top notch.
    Again, well said!

    Gord

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  11. I just watched this and went searching because I knew it was either at yours or Laura’s that I first heard of it. Just as you say, a good time and a pleasure of a rarity. Fun, solid B with many good parts, mainly Janis Paige. And even liked Smith here when I usually find him on the boring side.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.