The Tall T

Some things a man can’t ride around…

The first official entry in the Budd Boetticher / Ranown cycle of westerns is The Tall T (1957). The story here was adapted by Burt Kennedy from an Elmore Leonard short story called The Captives. That makes for an impressive set of credits and, in truth, the end result is a near perfect film. Once again Boetticher and Kennedy boil the western down to its absolute essentials, and the bulk of the action involves just five people and how they all relate to one another. Everything from location and plot to dialogue is pared right down and the film is all the better for that. What is left is a raw and visceral western with a strong moral current running through it and characters who we actually care about.

For a film with a short running time – under 80 minutes – it’s really a story with two distinct parts. The opening section introduces the character of Pat Brennan (Randolph Scott), a happy-go-lucky type in the process of building up his newly acquired ranch. He comes across as a gently charming sort who stops off on his way to town to pass the time of day with the local stationmaster and his young son. He even takes the time in town to pick up some candy for the boy as he had promised to do. When he visits his former employer, and loses his horse in an ill-judged wager, you start to wonder how such a hapless innocent could survive in a harsh environment. It is from this point on though that the depth of Brennan’s character begins to become apparent. Hitching a ride on a private stagecoach, hired for the honeymoon of Mrs. Mimms (Maureen O’Sullivan) and her gold-digging chiseller of a husband, he stops off to deliver the candy to the stationmaster’s boy. The station has been taken over by outlaw Frank (Richard Boone) and his two sidekicks (Henry Silva and Skip Homeier) with the aim of holding up the regular stage. Faced with the horror of what has just taken place, and the likely fate awaiting him and the other hostages, the character of Brennan undergoes a sea change. Almost immediately the easy-going ex-ramrod is transformed into a cool, calculating avenger who knows he must now play for time while waiting for the opportunity save himself and the woman. It’s a credit to all involved that this transition appears so natural as to be nearly seamless.

Scott’s flinty features once again blend in with the bleak Lone Pine locations which dominate the picture. The character shift I mentioned is magnificently achieved in the scene where the fate of the stationmaster and his boy is revealed in cold, matter-of-fact fashion by Henry Silva. Scott’s face hardens almost imperceptibly yet the meaning is all too clear. This kind of thing makes for great screen acting and the lead was a pastmaster in the art of underplayed emotion. Richard Boone was always interesting to watch, and in Frank he gives a fascinating performance as the outlaw you want to sympathise with. When he dispatches Mrs. Mimm’s husband, whose craven character offends his own personal morality, it’s difficult not to feel some grudging admiration. The two subsidiary villains are of less interest, but Silva manages to tap into a vaguely detached psychosis that works very well. Maureen O’Sullivan has an unglamorous role which offers her the chance to play something which is a cut above the standard damsel in distress. The fact that we get such well rounded characters in a short run time speaks volumes about the writing skills of Burt Kennedy. Boetticher again excels at making a cheaply produced picture look far more expensive. The framing and camera placement are miles away from the usual point and shoot style employed in low budget fare; this man had a real flair for the quirky and the unexpected. His handling of the action scenes is again exemplary, and they have both a frankly brutal quality and an odd humanity that make them stand out from other pictures of this vintage. There’s something deeply satisfying about Randolph Scott turning to the sobbing woman at his side, after the violent climax, and quietly intoning: Come on now, it’s gonna be a nice day.

Sony’s presentation of The Tall T on DVD is another excellent one. Some may carp at the amount of grain on view but I don’t regard that as a bad thing. The anamorphic widescreen picture is bright and colorful throughout. The disc also carries a short featurette with Martin Scorsese praising the film. Best of all, there’s the feature length documentary Budd Boetticher: A Man Can Do That. So, we get a great movie which is presented with care and respect – what more could you ask for.

9 thoughts on “The Tall T

  1. Burt Kennedy recycles the ‘some things a man can’t ride around’ line in ‘Ride Lonesome’ (and the fatalistic, slightly spine-tingling, ‘you know I can’t do that’ crops up again too), but as a fellow Fordophile Colin, I know you will be intrigued by his use of ‘murder raid’, ‘scald out’ and particularly the way Scott says ‘that tears it’ in that same film.

    I get the distinct impression that by 1959, Kennedy had seen ‘The Searchers’ more than once…

    There are a couple of user comments on IMDB to the effect that ‘The Tall T’ is one of the worst westerns ever made. I just don’t understand that kind of thing; the combination of Scott and Boone is just fabulous, the characterisation is outstanding, the story intelligent and mature and Kennedy has a similar feel for language that marked Peckinpah as one of the great writers of western dialogue. The moment when Boone makes his decision to ride back into camp is one of the most thrilling of any western.

    It’s only when shooting interiors are these films budget roots betrayed; thankfully, most productions in this set make great use of the exteriors, and I haven’t got a single problem with film grain – as you say, the transfer for ‘The Tall T’ is outstanding.

    Great stuff.


  2. Thanks for that. I’ll be getting round to Ride Lonesome over the weekend and I’m very much looking forward to it. I’ve really been savouring this set – I just hope it introduces more people to these great movies and, like you, I find comments like the one you mentioned from IMDB both incomprehensible and more than a little foolish.

    You’re right about the interior work in these movies, but I’ve found that to be true of almost all of Boetticher’s films – not only those in this set. He seems to have been much happier when he moved outdoors and his camera was free to rove around and take in the surroundings.


  3. Excellent review of an excellent film- and a great set every film fan should own. The story though, has always seemed to me to be similar to that of 1950s Rawhide with Ty Power and Susan Hayward.


  4. Pingback: Decision at Sundown | Riding the High Country

  5. Pingback: Ranown in Hi-Def | Riding the High Country

  6. Excellent review. I just love Boone in this. He really seems half in love with Scott’s character and his place in life. So vile and yet charismatic in this. On the new Mill Creek blu this looks and sounds great in HD filling the whole screen. Superb.


    • Scott represents the man Boone badly wants to be in the movie, and of course Scott recognizes that too. The performances here are beautifully nuanced and layered, full of glances and gestures that convey so much by seemingly doing so little.


  7. Pingback: Ten Wanted Men | Riding the High Country

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.